History of Sharon and its Environs

History of Sharon and its Environs was written by Adelaide L. Dixon from material collected by Sarah Graham Morrison and J. D. Shatto. The history or narrative of Sharon, Pennsylvania below is necessarily brief and has been adapted from the 1941 Sharon Centennial Celebration program.

Below the accordion is additional historical information from different sources.

Sharon Through the Years

Sharon Grew Through Annexation

In the beginning, there was Hickory Township.

Sharon began as a settlement in Hickory Township in 1795. The borough that was incorporated in 1841 came from Hickory like the biblical creation of Eve from Adam’s rib. For more than a century afterward, Sharon grew by nibbling away more land via annexation from Hickory Township (now Hermitage). A neighborhood here, a few blocks there.

The original borough of Sharon covered only the area of the present downtown business district and the North Flats, South Ward, and middle West Hill. It didn’t even reach the summit of the East Hill, stretching just far enough to include what’s now the F.H. Buhl Club property. The original limits of Sharon (current street names):

• On the west by Stateline Road (the Ohio line)

• On the north by the block between Russell and Curtis Streets

• On the east by First Avenue

• On the south by a zig-zagging line from Jennyburg Hill (near the foot of Prindle Street) to River Gardens Park (formerly Bicentennial Park) and Ohio Street.

Then the expansion began. At the turn of the 20th century, the area from Jefferson Avenue to Case Avenue on the upper East Hill was still relative frontier, most of which didn’t join Sharon till 1902.

Beyond today’s Oakland Avenue, State Street ran through farms and homesteads, many several acres each. In some cases, the dwellings were more mansion-sized than typical farmhouses. The family owners’ names linger on the street signs, like Stambaugh and Strawbridge.

As the growing borough (and later city) swallowed up more of Hickory, the East Hill was the place to build a house. Transportation helped the growth. The streetcar line was extended up East State to Buhl Farm in 1917-18 (service ended in 1929), and in 1917 tracks were laid for 5 blocks south on Stambaugh Avenue across Pine Run to King Street, 4 blocks west to Spruce Avenue, and 3 blocks to George Street (service ended in 1939).

The land under and around current Case Avenue Elementary (where the previous high school was built in 1923) and current high school sites wasn’t even part of Sharon until 1917.

Years of annexation explain why the spacing and sizes of blocks in the street grid is inconsistent around town. In some places, streets don’t line up at intersections. Some neighborhoods were planned developments, but with a different grid than adjacent blocks.

Fourth Avenue used to be the eastern city limits. And Forker Boulevard once was called 10th Street – not as a continuation of Sharon’s numbered streets but because it was the extension (into Hickory Township) of 10th Street, one of the 18 numbered north-south streets in Sharpsville.

Not all attempts to grow succeeded. Farrell failed to take part of Sharon in 1913. In 1925, voters of Sharon and Hickory were asked to approve a major annexation that would have grown Sharon eastward to Route 18 in Hickory Township. The ballot question failed. A 1935 plan to merge with Farrell to the south also failed, mainly due to “no” votes from Farrell voters. In 2004, voters from five towns rejected a plan to create a single Shenango Valley city by merging Sharon, Farrell, Hermitage, Sharpsville, and Wheatland.

The American Encyclopedia, published in 1870, when Sharon had a population of 4,221, describes the town as follows:

“A town in Mercer County, Pa. situated on the Shenango River. It has two iron bridges, two rolling mills, nail factories, two foundries, six iron furnaces, two planing mills, several small industries, two national banks, one savings bank, one private bank, three hotels, three large brick school houses, three weekly papers and nine churches.”